HEADLINES

Saturday, October 9, 2010

High and Hidden Costs: There is Nothing Free about the Wind

An island off the coast of Maine, suddenly became loud and unbearable when utilities operating three new wind turbines flipped the switch to "on."

THE FOUNDRY at Heritage Foundation

What was normally a peaceful, quiet way of life for residents of Vinalhaven, an island off the coast of Maine, suddenly became loud and unbearable when utilities operating three new wind turbines flipped the switch to "on." A recent New York Times article reports that some Vinalhaven residents are learning "the hard way" that wind power has its costs.

While residents welcomed the arrival of the turbines in late 2009, it is apparent that they did so with certain expectations. Those expectations came from what schoolteacher Sally Wylie call an understanding that the turbine noise would not be discernible.

Though wind farms produce emissions-free energy (when the wind is blowing), they bring certain costs with them. One cost—the wearisome low-frequency noise emitted by enormous blades—is evident by these complaints from Maine and from other homeowners all over the country. Complaints filed in 2008 by a Pennsylvania couple and a Wisconsin family forced to vacate its farm are just two examples of the financial and physiological damages of the whooshing turbines.

The deceit in this story runs deeper. According to the Times article:

Turbine noise can be controlled by reducing the rotational speed of the blades. But the turbines on Vinalhaven already operate that way after 7 p.m., and George Baker, the chief executive of Fox Island Wind—a for-profit arm of the island's electricity co-operative—said that turning the turbines down came at an economic cost. "The more we do that, the higher goes the price of electricity on the island," he said.

So wind power turns out to be more expensive than proponents would argue. But isn't wind already more expensive than our more conventional sources of electricity? Isn't that why it supplied less than 2 percent of the nation's electricity in 2009?

In a word, yes.

The Energy Information Administration's lists the levelized costs of various sources of electricity per megawatt hour projected for 2016 (in 2008 dollars). In 2016, both onshore and offshore wind are more than double the cost of conventional coal, and these costs don't account for the billions of dollars needed to build new transmission lines as well as the backup power necessary when the wind isn't blowing. This notion that "because wind is free, once the manufacturer builds the windmill, the cost of electricity generation will be cheap" is completely false.

One possible solution to the noise produced by windmills is to require developers to leave buffer zones between residents and the wind farms, which a piece of legislation in Vermont is proposing. But if wind is to help propel us toward the Obama Administration's goal of doubling U.S. renewable energy generation by 2012 or having 20 percent of our electricity come from renewable sources by 2020, then more wind farms will likely be constructed near homeowners. More noisy turbines mean more lawsuits filed about noise and potential decline in property value.

Clearly not all "green" energy is good once it actually gets going. Higher costs, hidden costs, and the disruptive noise that accompany wind turbines indicate that wind enthusiasts are not telling the whole story.

Emily Goff is currently a member of the Young Leaders Program at the Heritage Foundation. For more information on interning at Heritage, please visit: http://www.heritage.org/about/departments/ylp.cfm

Co-authored by Nick Loris.

RELATED STORIES:

Wind energy is a lot of hot air

The Big Wind-Power Cover-Up – 'green' slime of corruption

Stink in the air – Carnahan's brother gets $107 million for wind farm

Windmills killing bats by the thousands

The Great Global Warming Swindle – video documentary on CO2

Obama: Under My Plan Electricity Rates Skyrocket

The Green Con Job – higher 'green' energy costs = job losses

The Big Green machine – The Big Money & The Global Governance Agenda That Fuels Environmentalism

Big Green: Emanuel's pot of green gold is called Exelon

No Science, Fake Science, and the Deliberate Destruction of the Nation

Green slime – The people behind Obama's war against fossil fuels

Turning Off the (Incandescent) Light of Liberty

Windmills killing bats by the thousands

Reid to force renewable energy mandate in lame duck session

Wind energy is a lot of hot air

Climate propaganda still pushed by media

Congressman Calls For Schools To 'Promote The Agenda' Of Climate Change, Population Limitation

Education secretary vows climate indoctrination

No Science, Fake Science, and the Deliberate Destruction of the Nation

Texas Sues to Block Bizarre "Global Warming" EPA Rules

Rebranding the climate hoax

Green slime – The people behind Obama's war against fossil fuels

Warmist Slander of Scientific Skeptics

Turning Off the (Incandescent) Light of Liberty

Eco-Terror's Inspiration – Al Gore

Two Lies Make A Truth In Green and Liberal Views on Climate Science

Green scheme dims lights of freedom

Founder of The Weather Channel says sue Al Gore

Nazi Dreams were Green Dreams

Meltdown of the climate 'consensus'

Environmental terrorism: Alive, well and dangerous.

The untold story of Waxman-Markey: USCAP and the green industrial complex

Update: Enviro terrorist killed by police – Environmental hysteria causing looney lefties to go off the deep end?

Desperate Greens Make Desperate Claims

Reid to force renewable energy mandate in lame duck session

UN climate commission found flawed in investigation

IPCC and CRU Rewrite Facts But Can't Rewrite History

The Green $windle

Pushing 'green' for fun and profit

Run Like A Deere From Cap-And-Trade

Wind energy is a lot of hot air

Lone Star state won't participate in Obama's lawless policy

McConnell: Cap-and-trade 'dead' – but watch out for executive orders

Secretary Clinton's Climate Con

Reflected Sunlight Shines On IPCC Deceptions And Gross Inadequacies

Forecaster predicted Russian heatwave, Pakistan flood and exposes CO2 fraud

Banning the Incandescent Light Bulb

Hillary uses Pakistan flood disaster to push climate hoax

Leading US Physicist Labels Satellitegate Scandal a 'Catastrophe' for climate hoax

Cancer of Tropic – the Algoreaholics are still at it

Gore calls for major protests to push his climate hoax legislation

Why Warming Is Falsely Reported When World Is Cooling

Global warming lies, damn lies and easy rebuttals

Blacklisted Scientist Challenges Global Warming Orthodoxy

Big Green Lies are Imploding

Henny-Penny Discovers Feet of Clay

Global Warming, R.I.P

Leftist climate activist bails out of global warming hoax

Carbon Cronyism: Why Cap-and-Trade Is Not Dead Yet

The sky is falling, the sky is falling, the ice is melting

Dems Ditch 'Cap and Trade' but don't be fooled

What you should know about the lie that is coming in cap and trade

Dems change 'climate' saving language to 'pollution'

Cap and trade bill will clobber D.C. and you

EPA pushes ahead to kill energy industry

Obama: My Plan Makes Electricity Rates Skyrocket

Obama is Strangling Big Oil -$7 a gallon gas anyone?

No objectivity in climate debate

The Bait-And-Switch On Cap-And-Trade

Malkin explains Salazar's deception on drilling ban

New $3.4 TRILLION in taxes hits all Americans

Obama's Gulf Oil Spill Commission and the Missing Experts – agenda to pass cap and trade?

Obama Is Wrong; Alternative Energy is Not an Alternative

Obama Trumpets Radical Energy Agenda -Sen. Inhofe

Dems ready for big push on global warming

$7-a-gallon gas?

Krauthammer: Dreamer in chief wants to lead us down green path to destruction

Obama's 'green' jobs role model, Spain, is next European bailout

Green Stimulus Money Costs More Jobs Than It Creates, Study Shows

Obama administration hides truth on 'green' jobs with help of big wind businesses which stand to make big money with government subsidies

The 'green jobs' lie

The Big Wind-Power Cover-Up – 'green' slime of corruption

The Weatherization Boondoggle -'green' union money pit

The Green Pied Piper from Chicago

Billions for 'green jobs,' whatever they are

Myth of 'green jobs' continues

The Green Con Job – higher 'green' energy costs = job losses

Obama Still Backs Job-Destroying Global-Warming Agenda by Sen. Inhofe

Obama Sells Economic Snake Oil

The Great Global Warming Swindle – video documentary on CO2

Cap & Ruin also known as the American Power Act

Obama: Under My Plan Electricity Rates Skyrocket

American Power Act: Oil Spill Does Not Justify Wrecking the Economy

BP is Kerry ally on cap and trade (now known as American Power Act)

John Kerry's Big Business Buyoff to get cap and trade passed

Obama uses oil spill to push cap and trade

Crime, Inc. (also known as cap and trade) highlights

Nonpartisan Proof: Cap-and-Trade Is an Economy-Killer

Obama: Under My Plan Electricity Rates Skyrocket

Cap and Trade is a UN power grab orchestrated by Maurice Strong et al

Exposing the cap and trade bill as a criminal enterprise

Cap-and-Trade: A Scam Based on a Scam

Drive those SUVs! Global Cooling Is Coming — and Beware the Big Chill, Scientist Warns

Iceland volcanoes could cause climate cooling!

Former White house staffer & communist Van Jones on the father of the climate scam Joel Rogers

Crime inc.~ Joel Rogers & The New Green Deal

Al Gore's Carbon crusade: The Money and Connections Behind It

Cap and Trade is a UN power grab orchestrated by Maurice Strong et al

Exposing the cap and trade bill as a criminal enterprise

Cap-and-Trade: A Scam Based on a Scam

Cap and Trade bill would legalize criminal scam by Chicago Climate Exchange

How Obama's 'green' policies will steal your freedom and bankrupt America








Sent from my iPhone

No comments:

Post a Comment

Heritage Foundation

DrudgeFeed.com - Drudge Report RSS feed

RedState

Right Wing News

RenewAmerica

Hot Air » Top Picks

Conservative Outpost

Conservative Examiner

Michelle Malkin

Big Government

Big Journalism

Big Hollywood

Pajamas Media