The New START Treaty: Let's Not Make a Deal
At the height of the debate over Obamacare, when the White House's leftist allies were in full panic mode, The Washington Post's Ezra Klein accused Sen. Joe Lieberman (I-CT) of being "willing to cause the deaths of hundreds of thousands of people." Lieberman's crime? He opposed including an expansion of Medicare in the health regulation bill. Now that the President's signature foreign policy achievement, the New START nuclear agreement with Russia, is on the ropes, the left is again back to their hyperbolic ways. Ploughshares Fund president Joseph Cirincione told The Associated Press last week: "A delayed ratification with a close vote would be a blow to U.S. leadership around the world. People would doubt the President's ability to negotiate other agreements."
VIDEO: Governor Mitt Romney (R-MA) on Missile Defense START Critic Recommends START I Verification Regime Heritage Analyst James Carafano on Disarming New START
The histrionics are the result of a sudden surge of concerns over the treaty that started with a blast from Mitt Romney who declared the treaty "Obama's worst foreign policy mistake." Sens. John Kerry (D-MA) and Carl Levin (D-MI) attempted to shoot down Romney's concerns, but their responses raised more questions than they answered. Romney has responded to his critics by identifying eight problems with New START that must be resolved before the Senate can vote on the treaty.
We'll focus on three today...
>> Click Here To Continue This Story.
BREAKING NEWS: State Department: Russia Not Complying with Pacts
Today's Washington Post cites a State Department report that contends Russia is indeed violating international chemical and biological weapons pacts. The U.S. Senate will decide whether to ratify START, and seven Republicans on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee request the report. An excerpt:
"The new compliance report, obtained by the Washington Post, says that several issues raised in the 2005 version have been resolved, on subjects such as the movement of Russian road-mobile missiles and inspection of reentry vehicles. But the report may nonetheless fuel the debate over the new treaty, because it says a number of other compliance issues remained unresolved when the treaty expired last December. The unclassified version of the report does not identify them. To pass, the treaty will need at least eight Republican votes plus those of all 57 Democrats and the two independents. Most Republicans haven't yet indicated which way they will go. In recent weeks, the battle over the treaty has intensified, with the Heritage Foundation launching a nationwide campaign against it, and former presidential candidate Mitt Romney branding it Obama's 'worst foreign policy mistake."
>>For the latest information on the New START Treaty, visit heritage.org.
forward message visit 33minutes.com
The safety and security of our country has and will always be a top priority for all Americans. The Heritage Foundation's NationalSecurity.org provides accurate and timely information. Sign up for email updates.
The Heritage Foundation - 214 Massachusetts Ave NE, Washington, DC
Call us at 202-546-4400
Thursday, July 29, 2010
Fwd: New START: Let’s Not Make a Deal
Fwd: MyHeritage.org: Another Dangerous Leak
FEATURED VIDEO
Heritage's Rory Cooper discusses the economics of the response to the oil spill on Fox News. More videos »July 28, 2010 | By Amanda J. Reinecker
Another Dangerous Leak
There's another leak in our midst, but this time it's not oil. Over the weekend, roughly 92,000 secret military reports about the war in Afghanistan, dating from January 2004 to December 2009, were leaked by Julian Assange, founder of the website Wikileaks.org and a vocal opponent of the coalition-led war.
A leak of classified information -- especially of this magnitude -- could potentially pose a grave threat to American national security interests.
But as Heritage Foundation expert Lisa Curtis explains, "the Wikileaks exposé should not be used to argue that the U.S. strategy in Afghanistan is doomed to failure. The U.S. strategy in Afghanistan has been refined over the last year and new U.S. troops and civilian resources are pouring into the country. The new counterinsurgency strategy is sound and should be given time to succeed."
She also noted that much of the information contained in the exposed documents has long been public and many of the challenges highlighted have already been addressed by the new war strategy. President Obama echoed these sentiments in a press conference on Tuesday when he insisted that "these documents don't reveal any issues that haven't already informed our public debate on Afghanistan."
Whether new information is unveiled or not, the release of any classified military information raises important questions and concerns about national security and the rule of law. Heritage legal scholar Hans von Spakovsky explains why this matters:
Besides being dangerous to the lives, safety, and national security of Americans, this type of disclosure of classified military information is a federal crime…18 U.S.C. § 798 which prohibits the disclosure of classified information.Earlier this month, an Army private, Bradley Manning, was charged with passing classified information to Wikileaks. According to the law, von Spakovsky argues, "he should be prosecuted and if convicted, sentenced to a long term in prison, not just to punish him for violating this law and putting his own personal interests ahead of the safety and national security concerns of his country, but as a deterrent to others within the military and the government who are tempted to do the same."
There are serious lessons to be drawn from the Wikileaks case, especially as U.S. efforts in Afghanistan enters a critical phase. First, it underscores how, in the age of the Internet, it is easy to disseminate sensitive classified information to the wrong people. On National Review Online, Heritage's James Carafano outlines how the government should think about combating this challenge.
Second, the leaked documents reveal a level of American frustration with Pakistan's dual policy of combating some terrorists while at the same time harboring others. The Obama administration should reassure the public of its intent to obtain full Pakistani cooperation in the Afghan war.
Lastly, America's leaders should seize this opportunity to refocus the debate on victory in Afghanistan.
When Heritage Ideas Go Mainstream
In a long article last week, The Economist magazine discusses how America's criminal laws are out of control. The Economist explains one case this way:
In 2000 four Americans were charged with importing lobster tails in plastic bags rather than cardboard boxes, in violation of a Honduran regulation that Honduras no longer enforces. They had fallen foul of the Lacey Act, which bars Americans from breaking foreign rules when hunting or fishing. The original intent was to prevent Americans from, say, poaching elephants in Kenya. But it has been interpreted to mean that they must abide by every footling wildlife regulation on Earth. The lobstermen had no idea they were breaking the law. Yet three of them got eight years apiece. Two are still in jail.This is just one of the many cases highlighted in Heritage Foundation legal expert Brian Walsh's new book, One Nation Under Arrest: How Crazy Laws, Rogue Prosecutors, and Activist Judges Threaten Your Liberty. The bottom line: there are far too many criminal laws for any one American to keep up with.
As Heritage's Conn Carroll writes on The Foundry,
The Heritage Foundation does not agree with everything in The Economist's reporting, but this conclusion definitely rings true:
America needs fewer and clearer laws, so that citizens do not need a law degree to stay out of jail. Acts that can be regulated should not be criminalised. Prosecutors' powers should be clipped: most white-collar suspects are not Al Capone, and should not be treated as if they were.When a widely read and well-respected publication such as The Economist starts carrying our message, we know our ideas are taking hold. And we want our members to know about it. We're engaged day and night in the war of ideas to ensure that conservative ideas are considered in important policy debates. Thanks to the support of our members, we're able to do just that. Thank you!
> Other Heritage Work of Note
- "If New START is ratified, we will be saddled with a bad treaty that locks in all the wrong things. There is a better path to arms control, one that is fundamentally defensive," argues Heritage Vice President Kim Holmes. The latest nuclear threats don't come from Russia, but North Korea and Iran, both of which are left out of the New START treaty. Holmes offers an alternative to the treaty, citing a "protect and defend" treaty that, according to Homes, would "enable both the U.S. and Russia to reduce their operationally deployed strategic nuclear warheads below Moscow Treaty levels, yet leave missile defenses unconstrained." A program that limits nuclear arms and supports nuclear defense is the best strategic option for both the U.S. and Russia.
- The federal government already controls banking, the automobile industry, and health care. Next on the agenda is the National Education Standards, and the federal government is now aiming to boost its influence in the area of education. Heritage's Rachel Sheffield writes, "There is nothing conservative about national standards, which will further tie schools to the demands of Washington bureaucrats but do little to improve student achievement." She argues that while it's important to keep schools accountable, this is better achieved on a statewide level. If parents were given the opportunity to send their child to a school of their own choosing, schools would have further incentive to maintain a curriculum that parents are comfortable with and uphold higher standards in order to retain students.
- "The death tax is a drag on the economy that destroys jobs and lowers wages," writes Heritage's tax policy analyst Curtis Dubay. Unless something is done to repeal it, the death tax will be reinstated January 1st, 2011 at a rate of 55%. In his latest paper, Dubay argues against the death tax, and and is instead in favor of Sen. Jim DeMint's (R - S.C.) plan to repeal before it's too late. While some Senators are working for full repeal, others are working on a compromise plan to lessen the blow. Dubay reports, "Full repeal of the death tax would be the best stimulus for the economy to date. Allowing it to come back to life next year would be a huge blow to the still-staggering economy."
- What must Congress do to "restore the will of the people"? Heritage President Ed Feulner suggests three steps: Congress needs to repeal Obamacare, control long-term spending, and roll back the massive tax hikes that are going to take effect on January 1st, 2011. The 2010 midterms will give Americans a chance to express their will. Our leaders should promise to enact conservative policies, and "'we, the people' should hold them accountable."
- Join Heritage at the Family Research Council Action's Values Voter Summit 2010 in Washington, D.C., from September 17-19. The event will feature prominent conservatives including Phyllis Schlafly, Rep. Michele Bachmann (R-MN), former Gov. Mike Huckabee (R-AR), Bill Bennett, Star Parker, and many more. Heritage will hold a screening of Let Me Rise, our powerful documentary on education reform, and host a panel discussion about the connections between social and economic conservatism. Register at ValuesVoterSummit.org.
» Watch the new video about the event
> In Other News
- During an interview aired on a state-run television station, Iranian president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad said that he suspects the United States will launch a military strike against "at least two countries" in the Middle East within the next few months.
- "The United States believes Russia is not fully complying with international pacts involving chemical and biological weapons," reports the Washington Post. This news could hinder passage of the New START treaty.
- According to a recent study, $8.7 billion of the $9.1 billion designated for reconstruction in Iraq are unaccounted for by the Defense Department. Most DOD organizations did not establish the required accounts for managing the funds, rendering them vulnerable to waste. New accounting and reporting procedures have been proposed.
- BP's newly hired chief executive, Robert Dudley, announced the company is setting aside $32.2 billion to manage the aftermath of the Gulf oil spill. As a result, the company will incur a record second-quarter loss of $17 billion.
- In response to a liberal critic of his new book on the welfare state, Never Enough, author William Voegeli writes on National Review Online about the dangers of liberalism. He argues that "liberalism promotes 'policy without law' by having Congress delegate real governance, and vast discretion, to administrative agencies that go on to regulate with 'a vigor that is matched only by its unpredictability.' The consent of the governed, expressed through elections that let the people turn unsatisfactory officials out of office, is trivialized."
Amanda Reinecker is a writer for MyHeritage.org, a website for members and supporters of The Heritage Foundation. Bethany Murphy, Nathaniel Ward and Stephen Congdon, a Heritage intern, contributed to this report.
Donate | Heritage on Facebook
Fwd: Biden Claims $600 Billion in Stimulus Funds Spent -- ?We?re Building a Government That Delivers More Bang for the Buck Than Ever Before?
Today's Headlines Wednesday, July 28, 2010
Biden Claims $600 Billion in Stimulus Funds Spent -- 'We're Building a Government That Delivers More Bang for the Buck Than Ever Before'
(CNSNews.com) – Vice President Joe Biden says "Americans deserve a government that actually works," and he also assured liberals that the Obama administration is "trying to build a government that delivers much more bang for the buck than it ever has before." In remarks on Tuesday, Biden said the government has spent $600 billion in economic stimulus funds -- "and we're seeing waste, fraud, and abuse claims at just about two-tenths of 1 percent of the entire amount of money spent."
Hoyer Refuses to Rule Out Raising the Retirement Age to Address Social Security
(CNSNews.com) – House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer on Tuesday would not rule out raising the retirement age in attempt to save Social Security. "What I have said, in a speech that was pretty specific, was that I think everything needs to be on the table," Hoyer said.
EPA Puts 'Environmental Justice' Front and Center in Its Rulemaking Process
(CNSNews.com) - The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency has released a 55-page "guidance" to help its employees "advance environmental justice" for low-income and minority communities. "Achieving environmental justice is an Agency priority and should be factored into every decision," the document says.
Progress Towards July 2011 Troop Drawdown in Afghanistan Mixed, U.S. Envoy Says
(CNSNews.com) - Richard Holbrooke, the U.S. special representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan, when questioned during a Senate panel hearing, indicated that the progress towards Obama's July 2011 drawdown date is mixed, and he added that "there is no single answer yet to this extraordinarily complicated situation."
Rep. Pence: Medicare Chief Berwick 'Not Entitled to That Job,' Must Explain Praise for UK 'Socialist Health Care System'
Washington (CNSNews.com) – Rep. Mike Pence (R-Ind.) says he is concerned about the prospect of health care rationing following the recess appointment of Dr. Donald Berwick to serve as the administrator of the Centers for Medicare and Medicare Services. "I think it was wrong for the president to bypass the confirmation process at a time when the American people are so focused on legislation where the ink is barely dry," Pence told CNSNews.com.
Democrat Postpones Senate Hearing on Lockerbie Controversy, After Key Witnesses Rebuff His Request to 'Clear the Air'
(CNSNews.com) – Accusing Scottish and British officials and BP executives of "stonewalling," the Democratic senator who was to have chaired a hearing this week on the Lockerbie controversy announced Tuesday that it would be postponed. "We are at a place where no witnesses of consequence has the courage to step forward and clear the air," Sen. Robert Menendez of New Jersey told reporters. With the key witnesses declining to attend, Tuesday's postponement announcement was not unexpected.
Afghanistan Presses U.S. to Take Firmer Line With Pakistan Over Terror Links
(CNSNews.com) – Afghan President Hamid Karzai's national security council chided the U.S. government Tuesday for not taking a tougher line with Pakistan over its alleged collusion with terrorists operating in Afghanistan. The unauthorized leak of U.S. military documents revealing collaboration between members of Pakistan's Inter-Services Intelligence agency (ISI) and the Taliban and other jihadist groups may slow down Karzai's recent policy of seeking warmer relations with Islamabad.
CNSNEWS.COM VIDEO
Jermaine Jackson: Internet Is Helping Children 'Communicate and Adapt to Different Cultures'
(CNSNews.com) - Jermaine Jackson, former member of the "Jackson 5" and the late singer Michael Jackson's brother, told CNSNews.com that the Internet is helping children "communicate and adapt to different cultures," adding that the "world doesn't start or end here in the U.S."
HHS: Abortions and HIV Status Don't Have to Go in Electronic Health Records
(CNSNews.com) - Dr. David Blumenthal, the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology, says that abortions and HIV status do not need to go in the electronic health records all Americans are supposed to have by 2014 under the terms of the economic stimulus.
OTHER CNSNEWS.COM HEADLINES
Ariz. Sheriff: I'll Jail Immigration Protesters
War-Funding Bill Clears Congress, With Republican Support and Democratic Defections
Arizona Has Helped to Deport Thousands of Illegal Aliens, Even Before New Law Takes Effect
Bus Hits Roadside Bomb, Killing 25 in Afghanistan; U.S. Death Toll Also Rises
Ahead of Elections, Obama Ramps Up His Fundraising
Competitive Lockpicking, Called 'Locksport,' Growing More Popular in U.S.
Hundreds of FBI Agents Investigated for Cheating on Test of Surveillance Rules
FBI Defends Guidelines for Domestic Surveillance
Donate Today!
Please help CNSNews.com keep bringing you 'The Right News - Right Now!'
Make a contribution to CNSNews.com today. It's fast, simple and secure.
Help CNSNews.com and Donate Today!
NEWSPAPER ROUNDUP
New financial regulations say feds can compel diversity on Wall Street
Nursing mothers get a break at work, thanks to health reform law
Mass. House passes bill making insurers pay for autism services
Sen. John Kerry will pay Mass. tax on R.I. yacht
Voters say take action against sanctuary cities; Survey finds majority opposed
Arlington Cemetery problems were documented in 2005 but never fixed
Qualms build over consumer agency's power
House Dems may break with Obama on his middle-class tax pledge
Russia violated '91 START (treaty) till the end, U.S. report finds
Health bill for 9/11 responders to get House vote Wednesday
Voters can't shake deficit worries
Democrats table campaign finance reform
Anti-immigrant group calls for 'safe passage' of illegals out of U.S.
Gov. Christie vetoes bill to restore $7.5 million for women's health services
Aquarium to replace neon wave light with LED facsimile to save money
COMMENTARY
Hide-and-Seek Hypocrites on the Hill
By Michelle Malkin
You know when a politician starts a sentence with "frankly," he's about to lie to your face. The same principle applies to campaign finance legislation dubbed the "DISCLOSE Act." The voter's instinctive reaction should be: What are they trying to hide now? Drafted out of public view with left-wing lobbyists and rammed through Congress after bypassing committee hearings, this bum bill would have been better named the CLOSEDDOOR Act.
Out of Touch or Out of Mind
By Rich Galen
The Senate on Tuesday took a test vote on the misnamed DISCLOSE Act, and to the surprise of absolutely no one outside of 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue, it didn't get the 60 votes needed to proceed. The Senate vote on the DISCLOSE Act was a defining moment. It helped define a White House that has demonstrated it is out of touch, and may be out of its political mind.
JournoList Erodes Media Prestige
By L. Brent Bozell III
Tucker Carlson's website The Daily Caller has unearthed a treasure trove of liberal journalists talking (nastily) to themselves in a private e-mail list about how they should use their media power to remake the world in their image. The saddest thing about all this is the confirmation (as if it were necessary) that liberal journalists really aren't journalists first. They're political strategists. Liberal journalists in this crowd favor only discourse that "serves the people" – meaning, a "debate" that advances the ball for socialism. Any other uncooperative or unhelpful line of journalism or questioning or discussion or balance or objectivity is "idiocy" that should be "killed."
Fwd: Morning Bell: Surviving the Obama Assault on the Rule of Law
07/29/2010
Surviving the Obama Assault on the Rule of Law
Hours after yesterday's decision by President Bill Clinton judicial appointee Susan Bolton to preemptively stop enforcement of Arizona's immigration enforcement law, Thomas A. Saenz, president of the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund (MALDEF), told The New York Times: "This is a warning to any other jurisdiction." Just in case the message from the Obama administration and its leftist allies was not clear, Obama appointee U.S. Attorney Dennis Burke told The Associated Press: "Surely it's going to make states pause and consider how they're drafting legislation and how it fits in a constitutional framework."
But no amount of pause by states and localities could ever possibly satisfy the Obama administration, its amnesty allies, and activist judges like Bolton. In a textbook case of judicial activism, Judge Bolton rewrote the Arizona law to her own needs, invented her own facts and ignored clear federal law. President Jimmy Carter appointee and immigration law professor at Yale Law School Peter Schuck told The New York Times: "She rushed to judgment in a way I can only assume reflects a lot of pressure from the federal government to get this case resolved quickly."
The Obama administration's case against Arizona sought to preemptively stop enforcement of Arizona's new immigration law. The legal term for this is a "facial challenge," and federal precedent is clear that facial challenges "must be careful not to go beyond the statute's facial requirements and speculate about 'hypothetical' or imaginary cases." But that is exactly what Judge Bolton did. First, she ignored Section 2(B) of the law as written and completely ignored the section's first sentence that required an officer to have "reasonable suspicion" that a person was in the country illegally before their immigration status should be checked. Then, she invented a completely hypothetical case about a Chilean dog walker detained by a completely fictional Sheriff Smith. Finally, despite the fact that 8 U.S.C. §1373 clearly requires the federal government to "respond to an inquiry by a…State, or local government agency, seeking to verify or ascertain the citizenship or immigration status of any individual," Judge Bolton concluded that the Obama administration's decision not to enforce this provision was as good as rewriting the law itself.
Wednesday, July 28, 2010
Fwd: Budget Bulletin: White House Confirms Continued Trillion-Dollar Budget Deficits
Budget BulletinYour source for federal budget news and analysis
Recent Updates
The CLASS Act: Repeal Now, or Face Permanent Taxpayer Bailout Later Five Ways to Tackle Spending and Deficits Featured ResearchWhite House Confirms Continued Trillion-Dollar Budget Deficits
By Brian Riedl
The White House released its updated federal budget projectionsrecently. By releasing the report late on a Friday afternoon—a longtime Washington tradition for stories that politicians want to bury—the Obama Administration is effectively admitting that its budget numbers will not be well-received.
The "Mid-Session Budget Review" projects that this year's budget deficit will reach $1.471 trillion, or 10 percent of the economy. In nominal dollars, it's the largest deficit in American history. As a percentage of the economy, it's the largest deficit since World War II.
This will be the second consecutive year of trillion-dollar deficits that approach 10 percent of the economy. By comparison, the previous post–World War II record was 6 percent of the economy in 1983. Under President George W. Bush, deficits typically ranged between $160 billion and $400 billion (around 3 percent of the economy).
And the Obama Administration concedes that these large deficits are here to stay. It projects another $1.4 trillion deficit in 2011, followed by sustained deficits that never fall below $698 billion. The national debt held by the public—$5.8 trillion at the end of 2008—would soar to $18.5 trillion by the end of this decade.
These future deficits are driven almost exclusively by rising spending. President Obama's budget would push inflation-adjusted federal spending past $36,000 per household by 2020—$12,000 above the level that prevailed under President Bush. Even President Obama's enormous and anti-growth $3 trillion tax increase proposal won't stop this spending spree from pushing the national debt to economically dangerous levels.
>> Click here to read Brian Riedl's full report
Chart of the Week
Get more charts with Heritage's Federal Revenue and Spending Book of Charts
About The Heritage FoundationFounded in 1973, The Heritage Foundation is a research and educational institute - a think tank - whose mission is to formulate and promote conservative public policies based on the principles of free enterprise, limited government, individual freedom, traditional American values, and a strong national defense.The Heritage Foundation | 214 Massachusetts Ave NE, Washington, DC 20002 | 202.546.4400
Fwd: Morning Bell: 100 Days Later, Obama Still Failing the Gulf
07/28/2010
100 Days Later, Obama Still Failing the Gulf
Over the last four weeks, The Heritage Foundation sent multiple teams of respected energy, environment, homeland security and response experts to the Gulf to study the federal response to the oil spill. These three delegations, with more to come, have traversed the areas hit hardest by the crisis, talking to response workers, affected oil crews, fishermen, elected leaders and BP representatives. What we found is simple: President Obama's administration has turned a crisis into a disaster, and someone needs to be held accountable.
Accountability is in short supply in Washington these days. Fingers are pointed in every direction for our nation's economic woes. President Obama's favorite target of choice is the past administration for nearly every problem he faces. Yet, the oil spill has only two central characters: BP and the Obama administration. BP is (very) slowly taking accountability for its creation of this crisis. Tony Hayward was finally dismissed as CEO, and they have promised full financial restitution for direct and indirect victims. On Day 100 of the spill, it's time the Obama administration followed suit.
And what exactly does the administration have to be held accountable for? An environmental disaster made worse by federal incompetence. An unnecessary drilling moratorium that has pulled the plug on a Gulf economy already on life support. A claims process that was negotiated in secret, leaving few answers to why claims aren't being processed and transparency is lost. A slow response that wasted clean weather days as hurricane season fast approaches, and a decision-making structure led by politics rather than duty.
Tuesday, July 27, 2010
Fwd: New Common Sense: Under God, An Inconvenient Phrase
New Common SenseApplying First Principles to the Issues of Today
At Heritage
Is there a moral defense for free markets and capitalism?
Does Islamist ideology challenge America's founding principles?
Around the Country
Want to see experts discussing America's First Principles and the Constitution? Join Heritage at the annual Values Voter Summit on September 17-19, 2010 in Washington, DC.
"Barack Obama has managed a rare feat in American history: The longer he is president, the less presidential he has become." Check out James W. Ceaser's article, "The Unpresidential President."
Quick Thoughts
Will the First Amendment survive this Congress?
Senator Lindsey Graham misunderstands the Federalist Papers. Perhaps he has not seen our latest monograph.
What We're Reading: The Sacred Rights of Conscience: Selected Readings on Religious Liberty and Church-State Relations in the American Founding edited by Daniel L. Dreisbach and Mark David Hall.
"Under God," An Inconvenient Phrase
The Gettysburg Address is one of the greatest speeches in American history. In his short speech, Abraham Lincoln summarizes the first principles of our Founding and admonishes us to defend the republican and constitutional institutions essential to the American tradition. It is no surprise, then, that Lincoln's memorable words are etched in marble walls, or that groups across the country distribute it as part of a pocket guide. It is a surprise, when a group excludes phrases from this short speech and then suggests that fidelity to the text is irrelevant.
That is exactly what the progressive legal society, American Constitution Society (ACS), did with its pocket guide to the Constitution, Declaration of Independence, and Gettysburg address.
Here is what Lincoln said:"It is rather for us to be here dedicated to the great task remaining before us -- that from these honored dead we take increased devotion to that cause for which they here gave the last full measure of devotion -- that we here highly resolve that these dead shall not have died in vain; that this nation, under God, shall have a new birth of freedom; and that this government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the earth."
(Words in the original, emphasis added)Noticeably absent from ACS's version of Gettysburg address is Lincoln's reference to God in the last sentence.
In his article "God and Gettysburg," Professor Robert P. George of Princeton University highlights the importance of getting the text of the Gettysburg Address right. After all, numerous newspaper accounts and transcriptions of the Address, as well as three of the five drafts (including the Bliss Draft with Lincoln's signature) contain the phrase "under God."
ACS has since amended its version of the Gettysburg Address to include the words "The Hay Draft," without further context. George supplies the missing history of the Hay draft, though: "the Hay draft was found among [Lincoln's former secretary] John Hay's papers about forty years after Lincoln's death. It seems to have the greatest number of deviations from other drafts and from what Lincoln is known to have said at Gettysburg."
ACS further responds that George's concern for fidelity to Lincoln's original speech is unnecessary. After all, "the draft of the Gettysburg address included in our pocket Constitution is just that, one of Lincoln's drafts." In the end, it seems that the final text of documents is not that important. Good thing we are only discussing the Gettysburg Address and not, say, the United States Constitution.
Keep Reading about God and the Gettysburg Address
There is not a single instance in history in which civil liberty was lost, and religious liberty preserved entire. If therefore we yield up our temporal property, we at the same time deliver the conscience into bondage..~ John Witherspoon, The Dominion of Providence Over the Passions of Men
For more quotes, visit westillholdthesetruths.org
About The Heritage FoundationFounded in 1973, The Heritage Foundation is a research and educational institute -- a think tank -- whose mission is to formulate and promote conservative public policies based on the principles of free enterprise, limited government, individual freedom, traditional American values, and a strong national defense.The Heritage Foundation | 214 Massachusetts Ave NE, Washington, DC 20002 | 202.546.4400
Fwd: Energy Department Official Can?t Say How Much Greenhouse Gas Is Generated on Capitol Hill
Today's Headlines Monday, July 26, 2010
Advertisement – NewsBusters.org, the website you trust to expose the liberal media's bias every day, is turning 5 years old in August! Several activities are underway to celebrate this milestone, including a T-shirt giveaway. Every weekday between now and August 17, we will give away five NewsBusters t-shirts. Click here to sign up for a chance to win one. The sooner you sign up, the more chances you'll have to win! Also, be sure to visit www.NewsBusters.org each Friday for more anniversary news and surprises.
Energy Department Official Can't Say How Much Greenhouse Gas Is Generated on Capitol Hill
(CNSNews.com) – At a House subcommittee hearing last week, an Energy Department official could not answer a question from a Republican lawmaker about how much pollution is emitted in the process of generating electricity for federal government operations in the nation's capital. When CNSNews.com asked for the greenhouse gas emissions inventory for the federal government operations in Washington, D.C., a spokesperson for the Energy Department said that greenhouse gas emissions are not measured by regions, but by each agency nationwide. The spokesperson also said that in the future, greenhouse gas emissions will be collected by zip code.
Lockerbie Probe May Prove Uncomfortable for Obama Administration
(CNSNews.com) – The four Democratic U.S. senators probing the early release of the Libyan convicted in the Lockerbie bombing believe there were links to a BP oil deal, but their inquiry may have the unintended consequence of raising questions about just how strongly the Obama administration opposed the Libyan's release. Scottish government ministers, stung by accusations that they released Abdel Baset Ali Mohmed al-Megrahi to ease a massive oil exploration contract in Libya, are pointing out that it is the U.S. government that is blocking the release of two documents relating to the decision.
U.S. Spent $314,613 Studying Increase in Family Violence After NFL Upset Losses
(CNSNews.com) – The National Institutes of Health spent $314,613 over two years on a study that found family violence increases about three times as much on the Fourth of July as it does after the local NFL team suffers an "upset" loss. The researchers also determined that an "upset" loss by the local NFL home team was not linked to nearly as great an increase in family violence as were Christmas Day, Thanksgiving Day, Memorial Day, New Year's Day, and New Year's Eve.
Sen. Baucus Won't Say If Obama's Controversial Recess-Appointee to Run Medicare Will Get Confirmation Hearing
(CNSNews.com) – Senate Finance Committee Chairman Max Baucus (D-Mont.) would not say whether Dr. Donald Berwick, who received a recess appointment to run the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, would ever receive a Senate confirmation hearing in the committee that Baucus oversees, as the Constitution requires. On Capitol Hill last week, CNSNews.com asked Sen. Baucus, "Why didn't you schedule a hearing for Dr. Berwick?"
Schumer's New Campaign Finance Bill Preserves NRA Loophole
(CNSNews.com) – An updated version of a campaign finance bill written by Sen. Charles Schumer (D-N.Y.) preserves a controversial loophole that would exempt the National Rifle Association from tough new disclosure and speech restrictions during election cycles. The new bill, an updated version of Schumer's original DISCLOSE Act, was introduced on the Senate floor on July 21 without being referred to committee.
Massive US-South Korea Naval Maneuvers Held Amid North Korean Threats
(CNSNews.com) – Despite characteristically belligerent rhetoric, there were no reports of North Korean troop movements or threatening behavior as South Korea and the United States continued large-scale naval exercises Monday aimed at deterring aggression by the isolated communist state. A statement by U.S. Army Gen. Walter Sharp, commander of U.S. Forces Korea, said the drills were "designed to send a clear message to North Korea that its aggressive behavior must stop."
ACLJ Asks Commission to Make N.Y. Building a Landmark to Keep 13-Story Mosque from Being Built at Ground Zero
(CNSNews.com) - A conservative civil liberties group has formally requested landmark status for a building in lower Manhattan that an Islamic group wants to replace with a 13-story mosque and community center. The American Center for Law and Justice said it is "urging city officials to landmark the site because it stands as a symbol of America's strength and survival in the face of brutal, sadistic terrorism."
CNSNEWS.COM VIDEO
HHS: Abortions and HIV Status Don't Have to Go in Electronic Health Records
(CNSNews.com) - Dr. David Blumenthal, the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology, says that abortions and HIV status do not need to go in the electronic health records all Americans are supposed to have by 2014 under the terms of the economic stimulus.
OTHER CNSNEWS.COM HEADLINES
Mexican Prison Guards Let Killers Out, Lent Then Guns, Prosecutors Say
BP Says 'No Final Decision' on Replacing Tony Hayward
Fungus Blights Nation's Basil Crop
European Union to Adopt New Sanctions Against Iran
Classified U.S. Documents Leaked Online Give Inside Look at Afghanistan War
Obama's Message to Voters: Things Could Be Worse
Veterans Affairs Department Clarifies Its Policy on Medical Marijuana
WikiLeaks Says Documents Include Evidence of War Crimes
Ford Introduces New, Fuel-Efficient Explorer
Donate Today!
Please help CNSNews.com keep bringing you 'The Right News - Right Now!'
Make a contribution to CNSNews.com today. It's fast, simple and secure.
Help CNSNews.com and Donate Today!
NEWSPAPER ROUNDUP
Police, security bar people from photographing public buildings in Washington, D.C.
Geithner defends letting tax cuts for wealthy expire, cites deficit
Justice Department right in Black Panther case, commission official says
Chavez warns of US oil cutoff in Colombia dispute
Colorado Tea Partiers say Tancredo betrayed them
Howard Dean calls Fox News 'absolutely racist' for aiding Sherrod ouster
Al Franken warns that GOP Congress would bring 'truly dangerous agenda'
Wal-Mart plan to use smart tags raises privacy concerns
Atlantic City takeover another example of Christie's governing style
Heavy liability could sink small oil drillers
COMMENTARY
Wagging Fingers
By Rich Galen
The United States Navy, in conjunction with naval forces of the Republic of South Korea, is holding a joint combat exercise off the coast of the Korean peninsula to show the North Koreans that the U.S. and South Korea are taking its provocations seriously. We are, in a very real sense, wagging a finger under the nose of North Korea.
Fwd: Morning Bell: Let's Not Make a Deal
07/27/2010
At the height of the debate over Obamacare, when the White House's leftist allies were in full panic mode, The Washington Post's Ezra Klein accused Sen. Joe Lieberman (I-CT) of being "willing to cause the deaths of hundreds of thousands of people." Lieberman's crime? He opposed including an expansion of Medicare in the health regulation bill. Now that the President's signature foreign policy achievement, the New START nuclear agreement with Russia, is on the ropes, the left is again back to their hyperbolic ways. Ploughshares Fund president Joseph Cirincione told The Associated Press last week: "A delayed ratification with a close vote would be a blow to U.S. leadership around the world. People would doubt the President's ability to negotiate other agreements."
The histrionics are the result of a sudden surge of concerns over the treaty that started with a blast from Mitt Romney who declared the treaty "Obama's worst foreign policy mistake." Sens. John Kerry (D-MA) and Carl Levin (D-MI) attempted to shoot down Romney's concerns, but their responses raised more questions than they answered. Romney has responded to his critics by identifying eight problems with New START that must be resolved before the Senate can vote on the treaty. We'll focus on three today: